Marshall Mathers LP. Not just because it opened my eyes to what hip-hop could be, but to what song writing and story-telling could be in a musical medium. The world, semi-autobiographical life, and characters he creates are just astounding, and are the kind of thing that should make writers of any medium want to match or be better than. Other stuff I agree with Andy on, it tends to be my favourite albums grew on me, even if I really liked them at first, so for the most part there's not really many other albums I can say were better on first listen then they were on second, third, fourth, or hundredth listen.
People in the hate thread know I've hurt my back and am an idiot who still keeps doing things. Last night I laid on my front before bed and Poppy started kneading right in the spot where my back hurt. I don't have a favourite cat, but at that precise moment she was totally my favourite
I do hope they put up some fun DLC (pitches with various different layouts, 2 VS 2 VS 2 pitches and the such), I feel kind of like a dick getting this basically for free when I've played it so much already.