which is the better game ?

[Docpepper]

Well my friend said he heard Mvp 2005 had been released and that it was awesome. I'm figuring he meant 2004 though. I played a litle of all star 2005 and imo it is really glitchy.. so which is the better baseball gmae for the ps2 - Mlb 2005 or MVp 2004 or 2005 if it exists ?

[EWRFan]

MVP by far. I usually get tired of baseball games after 50 or so games, but I am midway trough my second season and I still play it twice a day

[Docpepper]

MVP 2004 or does 2005 exist ? I'm probably gonna pick it up off ebay soon

[Guest Sean O'Haire]

It is 2004. And their is a glitch for consoles that doesn't allow left handed batters to hit HR's. Have fun with MVP, because the glitch makes it blow. IMO, ASB '05 is the best

[JoeMimic]

MVP 04 for PC if you can run it is the best bet. The new patch takes care of the lefty bug and you can download all of the wonderful mod's people make for the game making it even better.

[Big Tuna]

MVP by a mile. I kick ass at it!

Corizzle: You don't kick ass at it, the lefty glitch kicks ass at it

Ok, the lefty glitch kicks ass too.

[Corizzle]

If your buying for a system don't get MVP, the Lefty Glitch ruins it

[djmasterscooter]

The Lefty Glitch is not true. I'm doing a Dynasty with the Mets, and Cliff Floyd just knocked in a 2 run shot. MVP 2004 is best by far.

[HailtotheYo]

I've never heard of the glitch. Eric Chavez has 52 jacks going into September, and I play the first game of every series (I've also hit about half of his HR's myself.)

I'm down the middle on the baseball debate. I'm torn between ESPN/MVP 2004.

There needs to be a minor league game NEXT YEAR ! That would so kick the arse.

[BNS]

I havent seen the giltch in MVP baseball either. I hit 25 homeruns with chipper left handed and 30 with him right handed so I don't really see any giltch either. And most of my left handed hitters have anywhere from 10-20 home runs enless they have no power at all.

[Big Tuna]

The Lefty glitch is really noticable in my game. Only when you play though. I'm playing every game and Gary Sheffield has 49 Home Runs.....in 27 games.

Edited May 19, 2004 by The Mark Of Excellence

[Docpepper]

I've heard about the lefty glitch but i believe it will be better than the glitch in ASB 2005 where the ball gets stuck in the ground or the ball magically appears in the fielders glove who is a mile away..

thanks for the feedback. I'm gonna go with mvp

[gunnar hendershow]

MVP is definitely the best.

The lefty glitch is overrated, you can easily hit homers once you get a pitcher tired. Though that's really the only time it can be done.

[Guest The Man They Call Puke]

MVP by a mile. The lefty glitch doesnt exist in my game, as i hit homers with lefties who have no power. I cant hit a homer with a righty...

[Numbahs]

I blind bought MVP last weekend....it's the shit. BUY THAT SHIT. The pitching is awesome, even in 2 player mode.

I've noticed no glitch in mine...I hit as many lefty homers as righty ones.