Baseball Sims

[DYSI]

Anyone, anyone?!

[thuganomic]

Baseball Mogul.

I have it, and I love it.

[Clawson]

Out of the Park by far. I've played them both and in my mind Baseball Mogul could barely pass as a freeware game.

[Big Tuna]

I say Baseball Mogul, since I've only played a little bit out OOTP. Baseball mogul was a lot of fun, so I recommend it.

[MSC]

Really depends on what you want. For a deep sim including firing/hiring coaches, morale, etc. go with OOTP. For a game you can pick up quickly and play, go with Mogul. Its like comparing EWR to TEW, it just depends on what kind of game you want.

[CKN]

Get OOTP6 my dad just bought it and we have been playing it non stop. The system for playing games is excellent or if you just want to sim(days,weeks,months,years or seasons) it works well also.

There is also manager mode which is practically the same as regular dynasty mode(if you want to call it that) but you create yourself(couple details on how you know baseball and business skills and personal info) sign a contract with a team. Each team has a goal(play better then .500 ball or win the world series etc.) If you fail to do this then they might not resign you. And you can also get married or date and have kids and later on in the game your kids could be playing baseball in your game.

Maybe it was just me though but I find OOTP6 much easier to navigate then baseball mogul.

[*RDB*]

OOTP by far..

[MalaCloudy Black]

I can't quite judge, as I've only played Baseball Mogul. How much does OOTP cost?

[CKN]

OOTP costs more but it makes up for that in how in depth it is

[sahyder1]

OOTP 6. It's a no-brainer. It's a really indepth game. Yeah it costs more, but the quality of the game more then makes up for it. I think OOTP is 34.95 but trust me it's worth it(eventhough I paid 24 bucks since I pre-ordered).

On a side note if someone is interested in joining a Sim IM me on AIM (sahyder1). We have a couple of small market teams open but they have a lot of cash to spend in the FA and will have high draft picks in the draft.

Edited June 20, 2004 by sahyder1

[Blitz]

I voted Mogul, if you even care anymore. I haven't played OOTP but I have played Mogul and it was quite fun.

[Big Red Fury]

Having played both I can safely say that OOTP blows Mogul out of the park(no pun intended). It is far more in depth and is easily worth the money.

[DYSI]

OOTP it is. Mogul is good, but not as detailed as I like. OOTP > BM... shaddap!

[Miami Vice]

I voted for Mogul because it's very good. I havn't played the other one though.