I don't really have any tips to offer (I'm not so good myself), and I have just this to say-- for me, it's about finding the right picture. I suck at finding pics, and I use mostly PSD-Dreams, with a sprinkle of WWE.com and google. Rocky told me to add a shadow effect (in GIMP, I don't know how to use photoshop), specifically the Alien Glow filter. That's mostly it, oh, and sometimes after pasting in the title, I forget to add the black border afterwards.
Funny thing is, Drew's also the US champ in my game:
(see where I forgot the border in that last pic)
CAN I HAVE THESE 3 ON A BIGGER SIZE?