Sig rateage

[Docpepper]

the cryme tyme sig is my most recent one the rest were done over a span of several weeks.

[Sweet Holy Moses]

All of those are super awesome. 9/10 for all (I rarely give 10/10 on anything), except the 2nd Kurt one. I don't like the effect on him, so 8/10

[Docpepper]

thanks for the ratings. my faves out of the bunch would have to be the Angle banner with the American flag background , and cryme tyme sig

[alldaws1]

I really like the second Kurt Angle one but I'm not keen on the text placement. I'm not sure what it is about the first, but I'm not keen on it. Maybe too much white.

The text on the Cryme Tyme sig is awesome but the cut needs a bit of touching up. I don't like how Shad fades into nothing or how big the picture is in the background as it's difficult to tell what's going on. The background picture would probably look better if it were smaller and up in the top right IMO.

The other sigs are OK, but nothing great. A couple of the cuts could be better but I like the text on most of them, particularly the Daizee Haze one.

[Cadet Ember McLain]

On most, if not all of the sigs, you can see little bits of trash, from where the render isn't blended enough. A one or two pixel feather should take care of it, if not a low blur...

[Docpepper]

thanks again for all the feedback have two more that I've done tell me what you think

[Cadet Ember McLain]

1) ---GOOD POINTS---

Effective use of background renders, and good cut for the main render.

---BAD POINTS---

Nothing major, except the way the grid is designed, it hurts my eyes a little. It's also a touch dark for a backing effect... The text is a little plain, but again, not a major issue.

2) ---GOOD POINTS---

EXCELLENT use of the scanlines with the grungy background. Makes the whole piece look much better. Once again, the render works with the background, although it's more subdued, which I like. Good glow on "Edge" as well.

---BAD POINTS---

The other text looks wierdly spaced, especially "The" and "Rated" being too squashed, and "Superstar" being too far apart. The lack of a border of any kind (unless there's a light one I'm not seeing, in which case, I apologize) lets the background down a little.

OVERALL: The Edge one is my favourite, although the lack of a border is noticeable... d ^_^ b

Edited November 13, 2006 by Kryptonite3d

[Docpepper]

thanks . theres a 1px whitish border on the edge graphic looking back now I should have used black. Once i find some good cm punk pics I'm gonna have a new sig for critique thanks again

[Docpepper]

finally got a punk sig done not too sure about the text put the rest I really like how it came out

[Future-Shock]

I would personally like the Serenity one a lot better if it had Mal or Jayne instead of River.

Edited November 14, 2006 by Future-Shock