To be honest, I don't really like either. I'll start with Cole's.
The idea you had for the back is decent, except the two photos on the side should be in the center of the top and bottom. The match listing could be improved, as it shows no sign of which is susposed to be the main event, whats for what title, ect. The front, imo, shouldn't have any matches on it, and Hogan and Rock should have been placed somewhere else, they look horribly out of place where they are. Overall, I give it a 6/10.
The back of CT's is very plain, but somewhat does itself justice. No real complaints except that it is too plain for my tastes. The front should have a main focus, and the logo shouldn't really be blended (unless that's just the version of the logo, and you haven't done anything to it.) HHH is out of line from Nash and it looks kinda of odd. Overall, I give it a 5.5.
Vote: Cole