Rate 1 to 10

[Guest Titan]

This is my first time at making a graphic and I would like to know how its rated. With 10 being high and 1. Anyway, graphic below

[Mountainous Cleavage]

Not that bad for a first graphic. Very big though, and I don't really like the text in the middle. The bottom of Raven just cuts off into thin air, which catches my eye each time, but other than those things, its good.

6/10.

[Guest 84th Chapta]

I like it good place with cuts dont realy like the size the text is really placed rite all over preety good for first GFX

5/10

[Guest Jules]

I'd change the blue stroke on the text, it doesn't fit the graphic at all. Also, Raven's hand is cut off. Aside from those, I like it.

[Guest Sensation]

Not that bad for a first graphic. Very big though, and I don't really like the text in the middle. The bottom of Raven just cuts off into thin air, which catches my eye each time, but other than those things, its good.

6/10.

←

[therockbox]

For a first try it's not that bad, but as a graphic it's not very good. I think it's to big to start, and the main bulk of text looks horrible. The PSD placement would be ok if Raven wasn't cut off at the end.

www.dafont.com is a good place to download fonts, and there are some decent tutorial sites in the resource thread.

[Guest Sesame Seed]

It is too big for a start, and the Raven cut is very bad, and the background isn't all that. The text in the middle is not too good (both content and the actual text itself). 4/10

[K]

For those saying it's too big, it's desktop sized

[therockbox]

If you're on 1280x1024.

[K]

Yes... which he probably is?

What's your point?

[therockbox]

It's only desktop size for people on 1280x1024? For everyone else it's 'big'?

That being said, for what it is it's to big anyway.

[K]

Ugh.

[AJ]

For a first graphic, 5/10 I guess. But comparitive to my standards (as in, what I deem 'good') 5/10 would be extremely generous. Too much text for a desktop. The cuts are cut off in places, white glows are bad, positioning isn't the best (eg; you've put cuts on top of letters in 'Wrestling.') Background is decent but nothing I haven't seen before.

Don't give up.

[CLOVER~!]

3/10(in my opinion), 6/10 (for being first graphic)