For WCW in 1998 I gave him 86 brawl, 33 speed, 60 tech. Probably high, but whatever.
Maybe give him like... 85 brawl, 28 speed, 55 tech? I'd give him 96 charisma around this time as his promos in both TNA and RoH were incredible.
Stiffness, probably 35-40, as he got kinda of lazy and it just decreased over time. Selling of around 78-82. Attitude of 80 or so, and behavior of 70.
Over? Probably 83 or 84.
Finishers are Evenflow DDT and Anklelock, I think, as he started using the Anklelock as a finisher... actually, that might have been in 2004. Eh, well, you could just give him the Evenflow DDT for both.