EWB Monthly GFX Contest: April

[EddieG]

After a PM from TheBusinessMan I've decided to create this discussion thread regarding the GFX Contest found

here.

So yes.. DISCUSS!

Edited April 10, 2009 by EddieG

[K]

Yeah, this is probably for the best, I mean the main thread had reached almost a whole page and it was getting difficult to sort through.

[IDOL]

So wait are you entering and judging? If so you should probably give your judging spot away if there is more than enough volunteers for judging.

[EddieG]

No, I'm still judging, but not entering

[TheBusinessman]

How is judging for this going to be done? score of 1-5 for each graphic from each judge and then highest total wins?

[EddieG]

How is judging for this going to be done? score of 1-5 for each graphic from each judge and then highest total wins?

More than likely, I'm discussing it with the veteran Norro

[K]

How many judges are there? We used to do Four judges, votes out of ten.

[EddieG]

4 offered.. I don't know which ones are still one

[alldaws1]

If needed I can judge.

[EddieG]

Well deadline's only just passed... it's a contest for April so technically.. we still have 2 weeks

AD; yes please I'd love to have someone of your level on my judging team.

I think the confirmed judges so far would be me, AD, and hopefully Norro.. so I guess maybe 1 or 2 more ?

[The Mask of Norro]

I've always preferred an odd number of judges, like three or five, because it avoids draws. However, and admittedly it's been long enough that I forgot, we've always done things like "9.5/10" and what have you, which helps lessen the chance of a draw and makes it possible for a draw anyway between the three judges.

So, that being said... four judges, judging the graphics on a scale of 0 to 10 with 10 being the highest, using an additional .5 for when the graphic is better than one number, but still not quite good enough for the one above it. I.E.: "Excellent graphic, with some minor mistakes that draw it back from getting a perfect score. 9.5/10"

Sound good?

[EddieG]

Yeah that sounds good. So we need one more judge. I've heard no reply of the other 2 guys who offered to judge.

[EddieG]

Okay Docpepper is our fourth judge

[Docpepper]

do you want us to pm you the scores ?

[EddieG]

Yeah that would be great.

Just to clarify once and for all..

Judges are

EddieG

The Mask Of Norro

AD

docpepper

And the graphics on one page.

[EddieG]

Okay, 2/4 votes in, all the votes that remain are Norro's .. and mine