Whatever you do, avoid Headhunter like the plague. It's worthless IMO, the only redeeming factor is that it has unlimited ammo or something when you do the training missions, but get this : You can't even play the game properly when you unlock it. For some reason, it won't save, or it'll crash or something, but it was reported ages ago when it came out. Plus the game sucks. If you want to play something stealthy, killing type game, get Hitman 2.
Haven't seen much about the Syphon Filter game, but it's prequels were pretty rubbish. Same thing goes for Headhunter, theres another game out there that does the same thing, and does it way better. Like triplxpac said, go for Splinter Cell. It's pretty much better than any game you listed there.
Psi-Ops might be good, don't know much about it.
I've heard Fight Night was good, Evil Dead probably isn't up to much unless your a fan.
Don't know about Baseball.
So go buy Splinter Cell! Out of the games you listed, I'd probably go with Psi-Ops. Either way, you don't like it, you can always return it
Brought to you by Kaneanite Game Reviews! B)