Am I making Progress?

[Jason.]

Here are 3 banners I've recently made...please rate them if you could...

thanks,

jason

#1

#2

#3

[Guest Grapehead]

1- 7/10

2- 4/10

3- 2/10

[Guest Boods]

3- 2/10

←

[K]

nah

[therockbox]

3- 2/10

←

Whats wrong with the last one? Its good.

←

[Jason.]

ObviouslyI'm not making any progress...

if anyone could give me some pointers istead of just saying "it looks shitty" and whatnot...

my previous ones, people have said they need a border, and I put borders on all 3 of these, unless that's not what you mean by borders...

any tips would be greatly appreciated, because I feel like my graphics are getting better but obviously they are not...

any help is appreciated...

thanks,

jason

[Docpepper]

first thing is to remember take the negative feedback and use it to motivate yourself to get better. Most graphics look better with a border but the border on your graphics were way to big imo.

Out of the three graphics above , the 1st one is the best but it's still average. the cuts are ok an the background is ok but the border style ruins it , the rest fo the graphics are what I call plugin/filter overkill. Filters are ok but too much of a good thing can be bad.

I suggest you use google and search ofr tutorials for the app your using , and if you don't want to search , pull out the manual , if you really want to learn thats the best place to start.

don't get mad at everybody for their comments , the graphics are rubbish but with work you can get better

[Jason.]

thanks for the input doc...

I apologize if I came off as being rude or upset...

I appreciate all the feedback, and I'm trying to get better...

A lot of the times with tutorials I don't understand a lot of what they are saying, but I'll continue to try and hopefully i'll make some progress...

again, I apologize...

thanks again,

jason

[Cactus Drags]

When people say your graphics need a border, they mean like a 1 pixel black line around the edge, not the frilly pattern type stuff you've got going on.

[Docpepper]

if you can't follow the tutorials then you need to read the manual to get the basics down