The Mafia Discussion Thread

[NobBe Nobbs]

I've seen some bad moves in my time, but Ace triggering Rock-Paper-Scissors at the first opportunity in Mafia V takes some sort of edible sweet.

[Matt]

Surely Rashid broke a rule there by letting everyone know he'd seen Melkon Firebane's role.

[Sousa]

I dunno, Pleather roleclaiming as Sandman was always my favorite.

[Mr Evil Guy]

I think I remember that. Jobber right? Jobber 2? or Jobber 1? Which is the one that I won? Oh? I won both of them? Oh? Oh, ok, ok.

[Sousa]

That claim's not really any good any more since FD won 1 and 3 and very nearly won 2. And you died miserably on the first day of 3.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Surely Rashid broke a rule there by letting everyone know he'd seen Melkon Firebane's role.

Meh. Melkon could have just said "that never happened", we all considered Rashid stupid enough that he could have been making that up.

[Mr Evil Guy]

That claim's not really any good any more since FD won 1 and 3 and very nearly won 2. And you died miserably on the first day of 3.

First night. :@

I was MVP of one, so I win.

[Matt]

Surely Rashid broke a rule there by letting everyone know he'd seen Melkon Firebane's role.

Meh. Melkon could have just said "that never happened", we all considered Rashid stupid enough that he could have been making that up.

I accept that but he still broke a rule surely.

[Sousa]

Yeah, but all and sundry were also after you Night 1. I think you were on track to be the first lynch in that game, honestly, after you made your tragically untrue "the mafia is usually this" post.

FD, meanwhile, lived up to my expectation of goofy Who posts that whole game.

So I call it a draw.

[NobBe Nobbs]

That claim's not really any good any more since FD won 1 and 3 and very nearly won 2. And you died miserably on the first day of 3.

First night. :@

I was MVP of one, so I win.

So was I :@

[Mr Evil Guy]

Yeah, but all and sundry were also after you Night 1. I think you were on track to be the first lynch in that game, honestly, after you made your tragically untrue "the mafia is usually this" post.

FD, meanwhile, lived up to my expectation of goofy Who posts that whole game.

So I call it a draw.

I legitimately believed that.

And I would not have been lynched. I would've been investigated and come out as the masked mexican wrestler I was supposed to. Then I would steer the town to failure. :@!

[Sousa]

As opposed to the way it actually went, where the McMahon Logging Company did a laughably bad job of getting anything done at all?

[Mr Evil Guy]

I'm over it.

[MasterOfPain]

Also, while we're talking about bad play, how about my play in DBZ?

[C-MIL]

My worst play would probably be in Silent Hill, although that's soon to be eclipsed by Sousa's whatever-it's-called-lawyer game...

[Mr Evil Guy]

My worst move was when I was starting mafia, in like my first two games the entire game went on my vote and I voted the wrong way both times.

[Jimmy]

Also, while we're talking about bad play, how about my play in DBZ?

Yeah, that was painful.

[Blaze09]

Naw, me in Jobber Mafia 2 was horrible, and don't forget me in CHIKARA 1 being totally dumb and breaking the rules. But I think I have gotten smarter over the months

[Ruki]

Next game, I am breaking out the "I was over at *persons* house, and I seen their PM! THEY ARE MAIFA~!"

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Except we know you don't know any of us in real life other than Kou.