Matt vs. Giveemwar - VOTING THREAD

[Matt]

Matt's Entry:

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Giveemwar's Entry:

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Winner is person with most votes after 24 hours. (So we'll call it 5pm GMT on Tuesday 28th October). Feel free to reply with reasons/criticism/whatever.

[K]

Does best mean most visually appealing, or least racist? (Not that that would change my vote)

[Matt]

Does best mean most visually appealing, or least racist? (Not that that would change my vote)

Both.

[Katsuya]

I voted for Matt's. Giveemwar's is awful, which immediately gave Matt the win; the problems I had with Matt's was the text seeming a bit...basic. Out of place, maybe, and not with the usual Apple style.

[ZJ Penn]

Yeah, the first one's good, better than I could do, but that iPod Premium 'shadow text' looks like Word Art.

Not really much of a contest given that the second one is basically a picture with a line of text underneath it.

[giveemwar]

Does best mean most visually appealing, or least racist? (Not that that would change my vote)

Mine is seriously racist...?

Matt and I did this to free boredom, not as an "OMGz I choose you, CS3!" battle.

[IDOL]

I voted for Matt's. Giveemwar's is awful, which immediately gave Matt the win; the problems I had with Matt's was the text seeming a bit...basic. Out of place, maybe, and not with the usual Apple style.

Same reasons, the cut of Curry isn't very good at all :/

Vote: -Matt-

Edited October 27, 2008 by Big Dick Idol

[legendonline]

VOTE: Giveemwar

mainly for the title.. it got a chuckle. the only thing its missing is a cobra... then it would be awesome.

Edited October 28, 2008 by legendonline

[TEOL]

Does best mean most visually appealing, or least racist? (Not that that would change my vote)

Mine is seriously racist...?

Matt and I did this to free boredom, not as an "OMGz I choose you, CS3!" battle.

Probably shouldn't have put up a voting thread then.