Which foreign player has had the biggest impact?

[Turbo Yannis]

If I've missed anyone, please inform me. I can't help but get the feeling there's more

Anyway, which foreign signing do you think has had the biggest impact in the Premiership since joing their new team?

[MDK]

I'd say Chec just because he has forced Cudicini out of the squad for the season. Other than him, I would say Robben.

[stokeriño]

It's spelt Cech...and Cudicini has had to deal with injuries anyway.

Me, I'd say Robben's definitely had the biggest impact. He's certainly the one that's got people talking.

[Summers]

Robben. Followed by Alonso, then Cahill.

[fineintent]

Robben.

Awesome. So good he should play for Spurs.

[Asuka's Gonna Kill You]

Fuck Robben, I think Alonso is by far been the one with more off an impact.

Call me a Chelsea hater all you want but I think Robben is so overrated by people today that it's just pathetic. Cech is good but I'd still go with Cudicini, mainly because I think he's out standing. Heinze has been pretty damn good too so he's up there for me.

[FLiam]

I would say Alonso. Since the addition of him in midfield alongside Gerrard, Liverpool have got themselves the best central midfield in world football.

Robben follows closely in 2nd though.

[TMM]

Xabi Alonso is pure brilliance on the pitch. As good as Steven Gerrard in the Liverpool team if you ask me. Robben comes a very close seconds

[AJ]

I wouldn't say Heinze has made an impact but I would say that he's settled in best out of all. He's playing at ManU like he's played there for years. Confident, strong, a great signing.

As for biggest impact, well none of them have made a BIG impact but I suppose Robben has made the biggest out of those.

[Farmer Reil]

Definately Robben.

Why is Cahill even there? He's A, useless, and B, been at Everton for ages.

[lafunky xxvii]

Definately Robben.

B, been at Everton for ages.

←

[pigeon]

Xabi is our best signing since John Barnes, and pure class. Has to be him for me.

[evertonfan]

Definately Robben.

Why is Cahill even there? He's A, useless, and B, been at Everton for ages.

←

No he hasn't.

←

Edited December 5, 2004 by evertonfan

[Guest Dakendo]

Arjen Robben, for an immediate impact, definately. It's like he's been playing Premiership football for years. Heinze gets a mention, just because he's settled into United's team so well, and he seems like a general reliable player.

[Dan]

Robben,.

This was on talk sport the other day.

[Guest Pirate Chasin' Booty]

I'd say Robben, just because since he recovered from Injury Chelsea have been able to score more than 1 goal per game, I don't think much of Alonso at all really.

[supergrass]

I think Tim Cahill's impact at Everton hasn't been given as much praise as it could. He's scored a few games this season, fits in, passes well, tackles well, and I think he's been a good part of Everton's successful start to the season.

[G-O-D]

Robben, without a doubt.

He and Duff are the most lethal players at Chelsea.

[Dan]

Chec is a great 'keeper also.

[WS1]

Have to say I had my doubt when he joined, but Robbens been playing class. He seems to be bringing the best out of Duff as well.