Official X Factor Season 5 thread.

[IAceI]

I have to say I found Eoghan better in a kinda more higher tempo song like that with Boyzone. And Boyzone weren't overpowering him.

Not like Westlife can do when they walk out with JLS, some of the stuff Westlife are belting out JLS can't keep up with. Westlife sound so different in one line, whereas the little midget from JLS (I can only ever remember him and the one who looks like a downs kid) just sounds the same every time.

Come on Alexandra

[Sir Alan LCSugar]

I liked the performance by JLS just then for some reason. Was good.

Edited December 13, 2008 by L.C.S

[Asuka's Gonna Kill You]

Westlife made them look like the average group that they are. Huge potential ruined by a crazy mentor who's trying to take the soul and proper stuff they should be doing away and making them look like fucking Wham

[IAceI]

Now that's the Eoghan I remember! I can't say I would have thought the song was any different he was there or not. I really couldn't hear him for much of that song, seemed like there was too much going on.

But with the judge's comments, maybe I just couldn't pick out his voice? :-\

[Katsuya]

Voting face ALERT.

I hope they don't murder Umbrella again.

[Sam]

Alex to win! Even if there was little singing done with Beyonce! I totally understand why though as she totally eclipses the other guest singers.

[TMM]

I cannot take this song seriously after Seann William Scott sung it in Evolution. I actually don't care who wins.

[Asuka's Gonna Kill You]

Beyonce just made just about every female singer look almost laughable. Not her biggest fan but fuck her voice is just out of this world, it's probably better live than what it is on a CD version.

Owen to win

[Walker]

Alex was completely and utterly upstaged by Beyonce, and she just embarrassed herself with what she did afterwords. I was cringing on her behalf.

I am still supporting JLS, i thought their first and third songs were better than the other two's. Second song wasn't as good.

Edited December 13, 2008 by WalkerWGZ

[AJ]

I don't think Alex embarrassed herself at all. If anything her being in complete and total awe in the presence of Beyonce is endearing her to the fans far, far more than being mates with Stevie Wonder ever would.

The way Beyonce can just walk on stage, wrap her arm round her and be so relaxed and still sing like that is mindblowing. Credit to Alex for being able to finish the song, nevermind sound incredible in doing so. It's a farce if she doesn't win.

[Dynamite]

Alex gets Beyonce whilst JLS get the almighty Westlife. Seems fair to me.

[IAceI]

Westlife are fucking awesome :@

[Katsuya]

Well, there we go...I'm happy now.

[Scott McFly]

Bye Eoghan. Thank fuck.

[IAceI]

Stop being so gracious and nice dammit! I want to hate you!

All I can think now is that he needs to lose the earrings, because he did seem like a genuinely nice person there. Fucking hell. Be a cunt and let me hate you for a good reason!

[Katsuya]

...incredible. She has to win. It's simple.

[IAceI]

I think that performance by Alexandra has pretty much cleared any doubts over who the most talented act on the show is right now. I don't think JLS are bad, but if any version of Hallelujah is going to number 1, it should be Alexandra. (Well, assuming Jeff Buckley's or Leonard Cohen's don't make it, although I see Buckley's cover is near the top 40 and could well push up further.)

She's done really well. A bit annoying with the crying, sure, but I guess it probably is quite an emotional thing

[Katsuya]

Boys Boys Boys, I like boys in cars?

Oh wait, no, sorry. Not GaGa songs. Yet.

[IAceI]

Wahey. Was the obvious and right choice, but still good to see it happen for real.

Odds that she cries?

EDIT: Sorry too late

Edited December 13, 2008 by IAceI

[FireDoughnut]

Ugh.

Leona II... Ugh.