Avengers/West Coast Avengers Mafia

[GoGo Yubari]

I'd replace JHS with D-Day on that list for sure since she hasn't played a game in ages anyway. I think C-MIL should be in the main game too but I'm not sure who I'd substitute for him.

[Your Mom]

For my two cents? I think MEG's list is sound, but put D-Day and C-MIL into the main game and Srar and Essa into West Coast. At a push, you could also include TRW in the main game and me in the West Coast. The only game I even remember Srar being in was the game in which she got five separate abilities as an indirect consequence of Hajj screwing up and winning, one of which was immunity to be nightkilled at least once. Slogger could win with that set of abilities.

Hey don't downgrade me just because you can't remember! And as far as Xmen goes I actually already had 3 abilities before Hajj screwed up and no one suspected me of anything until then and even after that I convinced people to kill others before me I didn't do too bad.

But as I said before I don't care which one I'm in. So if it will bother people stick me on the West Coast.

Edited September 14, 2008 by Pris

[NobBe Nobbs]

We should really have a proper poll about this shit.

Oh holy crap. This is what you had to work with from the start:

1. Colossus – Protect from one night kill

2. Wolverine – 50% lost on each life attempt, with 10% health returning each day.

3. Beast – Immune from nighttime abilities (other than death)

That's not just broken, that's utterly shattered

Edited September 14, 2008 by Be Engarde

[-A-]

Whoever the couple of good players are in West Coast will certainly end up nightkilled immediately, so it probably does make a difference

[Your Mom]

We should really have a proper poll about this shit.

Oh holy crap. This is what you had to work with from the start:

1. Colossus – Protect from one night kill

2. Wolverine – 50% lost on each life attempt, with 10% health returning each day.

3. Beast – Immune from nighttime abilities (other than death)

That's not just broken, that's utterly shattered

I can't help that I made good picks

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Thank you Avenged!

Thanks a lot for the feedback guys...you've narrowed down a lot of the same "on the bubble" players I did, so it's good to hear others' opinions.

Keep 'em coming, because role decisions won't be made (and role PMs sent) until sometime after TPP's up, which likely means morning.

[Pesci]

Going by MEG's list as a guide, I'd definitely have -A- and C-MIL in the higher reputation game. Most of the people talked about could go either way really, but if it were my choice they'd be in the 18 highest rated, or however we're wording it.

[C-MIL]

Is anyone else enjoying the irony of the 32nd sign-up?

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

It's like the hunter becoming the hunted, only in reverse!

[Ruki]

...I totally missed this, and that makes me sad. I guess I'll have to be the reserve

[Blaze09]

Ruki makes 32 YAY!

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Avenged made 32 already. >_<

[GoGo Yubari]

And probably makes selection of the 18 for the a-game even more bothersome.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

It's actually the 14 that's giving me more trouble.

[Blaze09]

Damn I did not see Avenged's in my bad

[TGC]

I could see why I would be on the B Game as opposed to the A Game. My Mafia rep isn't the best thus far. C-Mil should most assuredly be on the A Game however.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Sending out roles now.

[Ruki]

Should still take out a jobber for me