Jump to content

Rafael

Members
  • Posts

    2,764
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    9

Posts posted by Rafael

  1. 5 hours ago, David Marrio said:

    There doesn't seem to be many quality English centre backs coming through the ranks. Whether that's down to them not being the chance or not being good enough or a combo of the two. 

    Only really promising English centre back atm is Stones. 

    Stones and Smalling have found their feet. It's not  Ferdinand/Terry/Woodgate anymore, but it's good.

    I think England's biggest problem is their coach, Roy Hogdson. I know the top guys don't want to be in his position (as England manager), but trying to get a young, modern, hungry guy (someone like Eddie Howe for example) would be a better ask than a mediocre manager like Roy.

  2. It's mad how Payet and Wijnaldum have ended up at West Ham and Newcastle. Top, top players.

    Although it is good for the league to see these players ply their craft for the lesser teams so to speak. Part of the reason the league seems more competitive this season.

    I think it kinda shows how teams in the top 6 have been quite underwhelming in the recent transfer windows.

  3. Hornets will be fun with Batum! And Lin apparently has been good! And Zeller is playing well! And Kaminsky! And defense! GO HORNETS!

    I think this year will be much better for Lin as he can shift in and out of the lineup as a sparkplug offensive presence whilst Kemba is the main guard.

    This is what's been happening in the pre-season, he's doing what Mo Williams did for us but without the hero mode plays or forced shot attempts. Batum not being Stephenson also has been helping a lot, he's taken a lot of the ''dishing weight'' away from Kemba.

  4. Who was in charge of the transfers? Rodgers or someone linked to FSG?

    He was part of a comittee that included scouts and a couple of directors.

    The whole thing was the result of Rodgers not wanting to work with a Director of Football. During Rodgers tenure there were times when it seemed the comittee was buying players Rodgers didn't want (or the comittee were a scapegoat for players not working out).

    Add to that there were a few Windows were Liverpool were clearly targeting players and making a big hoopla over wanting to sign them - and not getting them. Last summer that seemed to get sorted but there's still strange inconsistencies that crop up.

    Rodgers patently said Liverpool weren't going to sign Balotelli. He also said last season's massive transfer spend was a one off. Liverpool bought Balotelli and six or so new first team players in the window that just closed. That seems to smack of problems with the comittee.

    To be fair,  that seemed to change in pre season. Every player signed in the last window, it was made clear by Ian Ayre, was of Rodgers' choosing. But it was not with out some public calls by Rodgers for FSG to let him get who he wanted.

    Honestly, aside from Liverpool still having a second choice keeper who cannot challenge Mingolet, it was a good summer of signings. Although it has come too late. I get the feeling Rodgers lost his way and probably some self belief over the course of last season.

     

    Well the players you signed are quite good yes, but Liverpool could have definitely gone for cheaper and maybe better options. Iago Falque was available at about £5.5m, Draxler was worth £18m, Dybala was about £25m. In total that would be £48.5m spent on three quality players instead of £57.5m on Firmino and Benteke. The market isn't as cheap as it used to be, but smarter windows can and should be made.

    I find looking at prices for what other players went for is a bad way of looking at things. Who's to say that Draxler would want to come to us for example? It's easy saying oh but such and such went to this team for that amount. 

    They were probably the best players we could get. Draxler for example is a guy who's been playing champions league football and will continue to do so you'd imagine. Dybala has went to a team who should win Serie A and will be in the Champions League. 

    The appeal of playing in the Premier League is starting to get the same value as playing in the UCL. Wijnaldum could be playing anywhere in Europe, he's at Newcastle. Dmitri Payet was a highlight in all of Europe, he's at West Ham. Gokhan Inler was Napoli's captain and now he's at Leicester. It took a whole 2 months for teams to show real interest in Draxler, who would be playing the same competitions Liverpool are if he was at Schalke but in a better league had an early approach been done. Dybala was at Palermo, it's quite obvious why would he want to move to a club like Liverpool, especially with the fact that he would start about 80~90% of the games playing in a much better league and probably earning much more than what he's earning at Juventus right now.

    • Like 1
  5. Who was in charge of the transfers? Rodgers or someone linked to FSG?

    He was part of a comittee that included scouts and a couple of directors.

    The whole thing was the result of Rodgers not wanting to work with a Director of Football. During Rodgers tenure there were times when it seemed the comittee was buying players Rodgers didn't want (or the comittee were a scapegoat for players not working out).

    Add to that there were a few Windows were Liverpool were clearly targeting players and making a big hoopla over wanting to sign them - and not getting them. Last summer that seemed to get sorted but there's still strange inconsistencies that crop up.

    Rodgers patently said Liverpool weren't going to sign Balotelli. He also said last season's massive transfer spend was a one off. Liverpool bought Balotelli and six or so new first team players in the window that just closed. That seems to smack of problems with the comittee.

    To be fair,  that seemed to change in pre season. Every player signed in the last window, it was made clear by Ian Ayre, was of Rodgers' choosing. But it was not with out some public calls by Rodgers for FSG to let him get who he wanted.

    Honestly, aside from Liverpool still having a second choice keeper who cannot challenge Mingolet, it was a good summer of signings. Although it has come too late. I get the feeling Rodgers lost his way and probably some self belief over the course of last season.

     

    Well the players you signed are quite good yes, but Liverpool could have definitely gone for cheaper and maybe better options. Iago Falque was available at about £5.5m, Draxler was worth £18m, Dybala was about £25m. In total that would be £48.5m spent on three quality players instead of £57.5m on Firmino and Benteke. The market isn't as cheap as it used to be, but smarter windows can and should be made.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. To learn more, see our Privacy Policy