If you had one HOF vote....

[sahyder1]

Time for EWBIV's first debate. Everyone knows that my answer to this is Bonds....I'll post up my reasoning in a little bit.

[Jook]

.............................

Who?

[Ananas]

Clemens easily, because everything Bonds does is invariably tainted by his supplement use.

[ACCBiggz]

Barry.

Hands down.

[Guest bruins72]

Not that I like baseball or care the least about it but I've got to go with The Rocket. There are too many questions with Bonds and the whole steroids thing.

[DMN in the House]

Clemens

Pitching > Hitting

[ACCBiggz]

Pitching is > than hitting.... but just one player, Barry.

Records all over the place including the most MVP's ever. And right now he is 3 times in the row, simply amazing.

[Jericho4ever12]

I voted Clemens. He has done so much in his carrer up to this point. And this whole steriod scandal with Bonds has got me kind of iffy with him.

[Ananas]

Pitching is > than hitting.... but just one player, Barry.

Records all over the place including the most MVP's ever. And right now he is 3 times in the row, simply amazing.

←

Roger's up there in tons of categories, and is second on the all time strike out list. Clemens domination in the mid to late 90's is unmatched. Bonds hasn't been able to match that domination.

[Typical Phenom]

This was on Sportscenter the other afternoon and I'll steal an answer from there as well. I vote Barry because when his career's over, you will be debating whether he was the greatest hitter of all time. Nobody will ever wonder if Clemens is the best pitcher of all time.

[Typical Phenom]

Bonds hasn't been able to match that domination.

←

What sport have you been watching? Bonds defines domination. People go out of their way to AVOID pitching to Barry.

[Clawson]

Bonds. I haven't seen a player dominate any sport more then he has since Gretzky.

[Emperor Fuckshit]

Barry.

Primarily because I'm a Boston fan, but also because Bonds' achievements are more legendary.

Also being top of Ks lists and so on doesn't the carry the aura of re-shaping the Big Three on sports' most famous leaderboard.

Oh, and Clemens is a douche.

[sahyder1]

Bonds hasn't been able to match that domination.

he's getting IBBs when he's in a 0-15 slump. Any further questions?

[Mike Ockizitchy]

I'd definetly have to go with Roger on this. GGWAB is right with the whole tainted shit. We can't really tell if he was on any drugs whether he knew or not. Plus I think what Clemens is doing is amazing. He's such a great pitcher. I'd go with him over Barry.

[gunnar hendershow]

One of the best pitchers in the past 20 years or the best hitter in the past 20 years.

Bonds wins.

[Mike Ockizitchy]

One of the best pitchers in the past 20 years or the best hitter in the past 20 years.

Bonds wins.

←

Yea, why though? Sure he won all of those titles and shit, but it's tainted. Clemens=pure animal.

You ever see Clemens workout either? Nuts. He's truely devoted.

[Guest The Man They Call Puke]

Clemens, because he has pitched extremely well, despite this being a hitters era....

[Assy]

I voted for Clemens. He is just as dominating now as he was when he started out for The Red Sox back in the 80's maybe even more. He could probably pitch till he was 55 if he wanted to.

[y2jerichoholic]

clemens.