The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Pesci]

1) GoGo or Ace - surely it won't be me

2) IAceI - one played, one won?

3) Probably GoGo, he's probably been bulletproof the most as well

[Guest King Tut]

4) How many different people have played Mafia on EWB?

[TheRossWalker]

I'd say just under 200.

[C-MIL]

138

[Pesci]

405

[nabeel]

111

[Pesci]

Considering either 94 or 104 have won games (I got lost in my counting), I'm guessing not, nabeel

[nabeel]

But what about the many accounts of Sousa?

[GoGo Yubari]

Probably GoGo, he's probably been bulletproof the most as well

Yeah, I remember there being a couple periods where a bunch of people gave me bulletproof roles just because of how I kept dying early. Occasionally it was even in games I played well in, too (WWE Mafia, for example, where I got the bonus of being able to rolepost as The Great Khali to boot).

[Guest King Tut]

Feel free to keep guessing...answers to come tonight...but not for a couple of hours as I want to watch Scrubs and was volunteered to vaccum the house.

[naiwf]

1) Ruki

2) Someone who has played less than 20 games and won about 3 or 4.

3) GoGo or -A-, although I'm probably the lowest

[Guest King Tut]

Data Table #1:

We have had 204 Mafia players. Here they are, with number of games played:

Spoiler: Click here to view

Ace 95

GoGo Yubari 93

Pesci 86

Ruki 77

Mr. Potato Head 72

Mr. Evil Guy 69

LittleDaniel 64

LCS 63

SSTB 63

-A- 63

TheRossWalker 57

Essa 56

FlatDoughnut 56

Josh-oo-wuh 53

Sousa 52

Be 49

Footjob Fever 48

C-MIL 46

oldskool 45

Split Second 44

JHS 42

Pleatherface 40

Jam 38

TGC 38

WFS 37

Hajjhowe 36

Slogger9 35

thug 35

The Evil Overlord 34

Rabid Wolverine 33

Whispering Eye 32

Gongsun Zan 31

naiwf 31

DMN 30

Hailtotheking 30

9 to 5 29

Huss Delgado 27

Momo 27

Will 26

D-Extreme 26

pizzamonkey 26

Blehschmidt 26

Marcos 25

D-Day 25

sirdavinator 25

Xero Gravity 24

Plubby 24

Kulex 23

SeanDMan 23

The Mask of Norro 22

Mysterio2000X 20

justblaze 18

Hugar 18

The Canadian Destroyer 17

Bigal 17

Evafreak 16

nabeel 16

ToffeeFan2K8 15

rocksta 14

Kaney 14

YoungB 14

Zaz 11

Kryptonite3D 11

Cloudy 11

Beeker00Zero 11

deangelo 11

LocoJCD 10

crazedfan 10

ChrisWalkerBush 10

Titocoolace 10

Avenged 9

wrathofcarnage 9

Summers 9

CKN 8

strongarm85 8

Heroin Bob 8

The Future 8

Tarheels 8

Dukes 8

Katsuya 7

LL 7

ChrisSteeleAteMyHamster 7

Apsham 7

Quasi Juice 7

Fanku Kaibutsu 6

The Z-Man 6

Fitzy 6

k-mac 6

desiredtoe 6

Gamemaster1026 6

Enforker 6

stokerino 6

Mongrel 5

Haloheadfire 5

bill_da_bill 5

Nick Adams 5

mattman1624 5

KevinStorm 5

Aaron Maiden 5

mAXi 4

TheTruth 4

Mick 4

Rashid 4

RazorsEdge 4

Reflecto 4

million$$man 4

Nerf 4

Heartbreak SOB 4

Wormmaster 4

Visionary 4

Jouzy 4

shane3125 4

Tkz 4

Cole 4

Neji Pwns 3

EddieG 3

Rebby 3

Green Demon 3

Protoman 2.5 3

Benji 3

RavenBlack 3

Gazz 3

Maxx 3

Krone 3

timmayy 3

SRN 3

Theburninator77 3

DazK 2

Deathp 2

DoubleX 2

PkmnTrainerJ 2

Lost Apostle 2

Big Tuna 2

Corizzle 2

xdavex 2

muddatrucker 2

EWFan 2

Neil_1113 2

King Ellis 2

TylerBlackMark 2

Nessosin 2

The General 2

Robster 2

Melkon_Firebane 2

Vector 2

Jr W 1

HeatlineTwist 1

Spee 1

Cat Alex 1

Zpsycho102 1

wpg 1

twoonglue 1

benkid 1

a. #63 1

badotori 1

Bartman 1

Bigsheep 1

SwantonEdge 1

Styk 1

Straight Shooter 1

TheArsenal 1

buck44 1

syck 1

KCC 1

lanky316 1

Isaac Mendez 1

JonDude 1

Jorden Snow 1

Alaki 1

ADGray 1

Kou 1

Knux Econa 1

Evil Chase K 1

IzzyX 1

Jaze 1

The Hypnosis 1

IaceI 1

Inoki 1

Jedi Knight 1

Future Shock 1

Jack_Attack 1

Jack Krauser 1

God-Awful 1

RK! 1

Dan 1

SKA 1

Meacon 1

Gareth7 1

The Rated-R Superstar 1

Small Blue 1

Sora 1

ruderrocket 1

13005 1

The Saint 1

ACCBiggz 1

Ekin Jones 1

Louis Lakkard 1

estebanmon 1

Marcus 1

nihilist 1

Dragsy 1

Michael 1

El Jefe 1

Mountain Dew Plunge 1

(I *think* I caught all name changes/double accounts/etc. Every game in the Mafia Cube minus the current Tournament and every game in The Cube minus Tarheels' unfinished WWE Mafia have been taken into account.)

[Sousa]

...have I really played 52 games in a year? Good God, I'm addicted to this shit.

[Guest King Tut]

Data Table #2:

Winning percentages, minus those who have never won a game:

Spoiler: Click here to view

IaceI 100.00%

Gazz 66.67%

Robster 50.00%

Deathp 50.00%

Wormmaster 50.00%

TylerBlackMark 50.00%

EWFan 50.00%

Lost Apostle 50.00%

YoungB 35.71%

Neji Pwns 33.33%

stokerino 33.33%

Gamemaster1026 33.33%

Benji 33.33%

Protoman 2.5 33.33%

Fanku Kaibutsu 33.33%

EddieG 33.33%

oldskool 31.11%

D-Extreme 30.77%

Pleatherface 30.00%

WFS 29.73%

The Canadian Destroyer 29.41%

naiwf 29.03%

Kaney 28.57%

LL 28.57%

ChrisSteeleAteMyHamster 28.57%

Katsuya 28.57%

Zaz 27.27%

Cloudy 27.27%

Kulex 26.09%

GoGo Yubari 25.81%

Dukes 25.00%

LittleDaniel 23.44%

Pesci 23.26%

Mr. Evil Guy 23.19%

Sousa 23.08%

Footjob Fever 22.92%

The Mask of Norro 22.73%

Josh-oo-wuh 22.64%

Summers 22.22%

Huss Delgado 22.22%

LCS 22.22%

-A- 22.22%

rocksta 21.43%

Jam 21.05%

Haloheadfire 20.00%

DMN 20.00%

Titocoolace 20.00%

Mongrel 20.00%

sirdavinator 20.00%

Blehschmidt 19.23%

pizzamonkey 19.23%

Split Second 18.18%

Beeker00Zero 18.18%

Mr. Potato Head 18.06%

SSTB 17.46%

Ruki 16.88%

Hugar 16.67%

JHS 16.67%

Xero Gravity 16.67%

justblaze 16.67%

Fitzy 16.67%

desiredtoe 16.67%

Enforker 16.67%

Gongsun Zan 16.13%

FlatDoughnut 16.07%

Essa 16.07%

TheRossWalker 15.79%

Whispering Eye 15.63%

Mysterio2000X 15.00%

Momo 14.81%

Quasi Juice 14.29%

Apsham 14.29%

Hailtotheking 13.33%

TGC 13.16%

C-MIL 13.04%

Plubby 12.50%

Tarheels 12.50%

CKN 12.50%

Evafreak 12.50%

Be 12.24%

Rabid Wolverine 12.12%

D-Day 12.00%

The Evil Overlord 11.76%

Bigal 11.76%

Ace 11.58%

Will 11.54%

thug 11.43%

Avenged 11.11%

wrathofcarnage 11.11%

9 to 5 10.34%

crazedfan 10.00%

ChrisWalkerBush 10.00%

Kryptonite3D 9.09%

deangelo 9.09%

SeanDMan 8.70%

Slogger9 8.57%

Hajjhowe 8.33%

ToffeeFan2K8 6.67%

nabeel 6.25%

Marcos 4.00%

(For those who are curious, LocoJCD has played ten games without a single win, more than any other player. Second is a three-way tie between Heroin Bob, The Future, and strongarm85, all at eight.)

(And the answer to #3 is undisputedly Kou. Signed up for only Simpsons Mafia, and was targetted by about six or seven actions - including a kill - on his first night.)

[Guest King Tut]

One thing that stood out at me in all this - even though the waiting list system was created to keep the number of games manageable, there's clearly far more games overall in 2009 than there were in say 2007 - look at how high the guys who are in every game today but weren't around then (Ross, LD, etc.) are on the first list compared to the guys who were in every game then but aren't around now (Kulex, Slogger).

[R.W.]

I think I'm just going to stick to running games now.

[Momo]

Hey MPH. I'm Jedi Knight too. So I've played 28 games then >_>.

Also, I could swear the game I played when my name was Jedi Knight was Anime Mafia... and I won, which would have given Jedi Knight 100% win rating.

[The Quasi Juice]

Data Table #1:

We have had 204 Mafia players. Here they are, with number of games played:

Spoiler: Click here to view

Ace 95

GoGo Yubari 93

Pesci 86

Ruki 77

Mr. Potato Head 72

Mr. Evil Guy 69

LittleDaniel 64

LCS 63

SSTB 63

-A- 63

TheRossWalker 57

Essa 56

FlatDoughnut 56

Josh-oo-wuh 53

Sousa 52

Be 49

Footjob Fever 48

C-MIL 46

oldskool 45

Split Second 44

JHS 42

Pleatherface 40

Jam 38

TGC 38

WFS 37

Hajjhowe 36

Slogger9 35

thug 35

The Evil Overlord 34

Rabid Wolverine 33

Whispering Eye 32

Gongsun Zan 31

naiwf 31

DMN 30

Hailtotheking 30

9 to 5 29

Huss Delgado 27

Momo 27

Will 26

D-Extreme 26

pizzamonkey 26

Blehschmidt 26

Marcos 25

D-Day 25

sirdavinator 25

Xero Gravity 24

Plubby 24

Kulex 23

SeanDMan 23

The Mask of Norro 22

Mysterio2000X 20

justblaze 18

Hugar 18

The Canadian Destroyer 17

Bigal 17

Evafreak 16

nabeel 16

ToffeeFan2K8 15

rocksta 14

Kaney 14

YoungB 14

Zaz 11

Kryptonite3D 11

Cloudy 11

Beeker00Zero 11

deangelo 11

LocoJCD 10

crazedfan 10

ChrisWalkerBush 10

Titocoolace 10

Avenged 9

wrathofcarnage 9

Summers 9

CKN 8

strongarm85 8

Heroin Bob 8

The Future 8

Tarheels 8

Dukes 8

Katsuya 7

LL 7

ChrisSteeleAteMyHamster 7

Apsham 7

Quasi Juice 7

Fanku Kaibutsu 6

The Z-Man 6

Fitzy 6

k-mac 6

desiredtoe 6

Gamemaster1026 6

Enforker 6

stokerino 6

Mongrel 5

Haloheadfire 5

bill_da_bill 5

Nick Adams 5

mattman1624 5

KevinStorm 5

Aaron Maiden 5

mAXi 4

TheTruth 4

Mick 4

Rashid 4

RazorsEdge 4

Reflecto 4

million$$man 4

Nerf 4

Heartbreak SOB 4

Wormmaster 4

Visionary 4

Jouzy 4

shane3125 4

Tkz 4

Cole 4

Neji Pwns 3

EddieG 3

Rebby 3

Green Demon 3

Protoman 2.5 3

Benji 3

RavenBlack 3

Gazz 3

Maxx 3

Krone 3

timmayy 3

SRN 3

Theburninator77 3

DazK 2

Deathp 2

DoubleX 2

PkmnTrainerJ 2

Lost Apostle 2

Big Tuna 2

Corizzle 2

xdavex 2

muddatrucker 2

EWFan 2

Neil_1113 2

King Ellis 2

TylerBlackMark 2

Nessosin 2

The General 2

Robster 2

Melkon_Firebane 2

Vector 2

Jr W 1

HeatlineTwist 1

Spee 1

Cat Alex 1

Zpsycho102 1

wpg 1

twoonglue 1

benkid 1

a. #63 1

badotori 1

Bartman 1

Bigsheep 1

SwantonEdge 1

Styk 1

Straight Shooter 1

TheArsenal 1

buck44 1

syck 1

KCC 1

lanky316 1

Isaac Mendez 1

JonDude 1

Jorden Snow 1

Alaki 1

ADGray 1

Kou 1

Knux Econa 1

Evil Chase K 1

IzzyX 1

Jaze 1

The Hypnosis 1

IaceI 1

Inoki 1

Jedi Knight 1

Future Shock 1

Jack_Attack 1

Jack Krauser 1

God-Awful 1

RK! 1

Dan 1

SKA 1

Meacon 1

Gareth7 1

The Rated-R Superstar 1

Small Blue 1

Sora 1

ruderrocket 1

13005 1

The Saint 1

ACCBiggz 1

Ekin Jones 1

Louis Lakkard 1

estebanmon 1

Marcus 1

nihilist 1

Dragsy 1

Michael 1

El Jefe 1

Mountain Dew Plunge 1

(I *think* I caught all name changes/double accounts/etc. Every game in the Mafia Cube minus the current Tournament and every game in The Cube minus Tarheels' unfinished WWE Mafia have been taken into account.)

Looking at that list it's surprising not more people signed up for Newbie Mafia, whereas someone like FlatDoughnut with 56 did sign up and he's and he's in the top 15

[SeanDMan]

FD isn't new to mafia, he's just a really slow learner.

[The Quasi Juice]

People who overreact are NOT always scum. Will gets pissed in Fell Mafia because Matt voted for him for no reason and his vote counts twice. Sure he overreacted a little bit but why does that suddenly make him scum? A bandwagon follows and he turns up town, so silly. You could say Norro overreacted too, although I feel it was justified but I've done the same and got attacked too, but nobody jumped on Norro after his GRRR post.