The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Carbonbasedlife]

That was beautiful.

[Tigerstyle]

Yeah, I feel really bad about the way I ended that game, I am a lot better than that and Rider even told me that and I tried but got so tunnel visioned.

I am too focussed on someone when I have them in my sights and worried that people will think I am non committal.

[EWB's Best Poster.]

It's fine to make a mistake. I've made a few while playing. I would likely have at least suspected Gazz.

[Gazz]

You wouldn't

[EWB's Best Poster.]

Suspect you? Nah. I would have. But I'd have voted sheep. Tiger had no reason as scum to demand info Luke he did and sheep hid the fact he was affected until he was caught. Sheep was clearly hiding something.

[Commander Sheepard]

Yep, I was. To be fair though, I thought that I had lost my ability by who I targeted, so I really wasn't lying when I said that my action went through. Or at least, I didn't THINK I was lying.

[Benjamin]

Thinking of making a small 12, 13 person mafia with the theme being an off-shoot of Pixar since we're in a bit of a slump now. Maybe Pixar Villains Mafia or a Toy Story Mafia of what happens in between Pixar 2 and Pixar 3.

[Commander Sheepard]

Sounds like a goodp idea to me, Ben. Maybe a few smaller games will get things moving again.

[Noah]

I feel bad for Red Devil and Mick but I have to stop signing up for things. I haven't even been close to my best for the longest time and when things go wrong (like falling to a random lynch in breaking bad on Day 1) or those inevitable heated in game back and forth text wars start up, it bothers me much more than it should.

[Carbonbasedlife]

I've been considering trying my hand at running a game sometime as well. Not sure about the theme but I was also thinking something small would be best. If I come up with something and it becomes more than a nebulous idea in my head then I'll put it on the list.

[Commander Sheepard]

Carbon, you honestly don't HAVE to have an elaborate "theme" to run a good game. It's fun to write that stuff out, but if you have the itch, just about anything would be fun I'd think.

[Nick Adams]

Would anybody be interested in another No Frills Mafia (i.e. just Mafia and Town, no roles)?

[Red Devil-Taker316]

I'm thinking of closing up my game anyway. It's probably not going to fill up and those who signed up already probably forgot or aren't as interested.

I think there would be waiting lists for certain game sizes (those lists should be followed to if they are there. I like phatman's idea obviously since I'm in it, but my game was skipped over and I don't think we can handle two plus 20 people games at one time). A waiting list for 20+ and a waiting list for 13-20, then one for like 6-12 could work out well.

[Commander Sheepard]

Isn't that how things used to be, back when the whole list idea was first semi-established?

[Carbonbasedlife]

RDT: for the record. I am still very-much interested in your game.

Sheep: true that a "theme" isn't necessary. And I certainly don't expect that anything I will do would be "elaborate", but I would like to have a world in-which to work, just because I think it makes the process more interesting for me personally.

[Commander Sheepard]

I can understand that too Carbon.

RDT, any chance you could run your game with reduced numbers?

[Benjamin]

I was supposed to take a break from mafia, I was horrible in Full Circle and was so annoyed with myself. The only reason I joined phatman's game is the theme, otherwise I would have joined Mick or RDT's game.

[Red Devil-Taker316]

I have designed smaller games as well. I can always run Nintendo at Mafia peak time again.

I'll go to the back of the list. I gotta fine tune some things for it.

[Mick]

I was supposed to take a break from mafia, I was horrible in Full Circle and was so annoyed with myself. The only reason I joined phatman's game is the theme, otherwise I would have joined Mick or RDT's game.

Still can

[Draevyn]

I was supposed to take a break from mafia, I was horrible in Full Circle and was so annoyed with myself. The only reason I joined phatman's game is the theme, otherwise I would have joined Mick or RDT's game.

That was me. I was going to take a break 3 mafias ago. I think I really will after Phat's game.