Footy shirts with collars. Yes or no?

[ChrisSteeleAteMyHamster]

I hate collars like this on a football shirt:

I much prefer a simple round collar or V neck like this:

How about you?

[Plubby]

Likey! Though that collar is a bit drastic. And way too popped.

[Baddar]

Normally I'd say no, but on the whole I think this season's United home shirt is the best in around 10 years, just ahead of our first AIG top.

[MDK]

Collar UP! So I can say 'Au Revoir' and blast a burning ball thru a ghoul.

[stokeriño]

I no likey.

Although if someone offered me a choice between a non-fluorescant Chelsea away shirt with a collar and yet another fluorescant Chelsea away shirt, I'd take the former in an instant.

[Dynamite]

If you're Cantona, yes.

If you're anybody else, no.

[Adam]

I quite like the smart, smaller collars. Like Liverpool's last few kits have had. Having 'em up like Cantona though definitely not.

[EddieG]

If you're Cantona, yes.

If you're anybody else, no.

x1000

[Hobo]

I actually don't care. Because I owned this:

And this was the least comfortable thing ever to wear. So anything that isn't this is okay.

[gunnar hendershow]

Collars work well but not when they're popped. Then it just looks sloppy.

[therockbox]

I actually don't care. Because I owned this:

And this was the least comfortable thing ever to wear. So anything that isn't this is okay.

Oh god, I remember that. Itched like crazy.

I did have one of these as well, which was brilliant:

[britneyspearsisgod]

As long as the collar isn't too tight, I can take it or leave it really. It's the design I'm looking at more than anything.

Although Bristol Rovers have had some terrible kits over the years and I've still worn them.

See?

[Lowerdeck]

Collars only look good for golf shirts, not other sports.

[ONO]

Ha. Funnily enough I'm wearing the old Villa away top with the collar and I like it. Very retro. I don't think I'd like it on the new kits though.

[Adam]

As long as the collar isn't too tight, I can take it or leave it really. It's the design I'm looking at more than anything.

Although Bristol Rovers have had some terrible kits over the years and I've still worn them.

See?

That may be the worst kit design I've ever seen. Is that really an attempt to do stripes and quarters at the same time!?