Have to agree with Billy Talent, great album, also I might even suggest that Billy Talent II would also might be right there.
I-Empire from Angels and Airwaves. I initially thought that only like 2 songs stood out (Everything's Magic and Secret Crowds) but I have come to realise that every song on that album is amazing in it's own way. I still listen to the album in full every now and again.
Enema of the State - every song is a classic to me. My favorite blink-182 album, followed closely by Dude Ranch
ones that might be getting there: '59 Sound by The Gaslight Anthem: each song is great and I have been listening to them for like 3 months tops and the entire album is growing on me.
Also Box Car Racer is another album that builds upon each song and makes a great album.
and thats all I can think of right now