Compared to the others he doesn't make my list. He isn't even on the bench. Nor the rotation. Bonds, Mays, and Griffey can all do it all. Power, Contact, Defense, and Base Running. They can hit that much needed HR, or they could steal a base to get in scoring position and manufacture a run. And on the bench you have some of the guys MSC mentioned and Ted Williams not to mention probably my #2 guy on the bench behind Ted, Hank Aaron. I just think as far as complete players I'd have Bonds, Mays, and Griffey out there.
As far as pitching goes, yes his numbers are good just like batting, but over time pitching got better and better and I'm looking at big game pitching as well which is why I put Bob Gibson on there. He is one of my favorite all-time pitchers. And I've expressed my opinions on Babe Ruth in the past and not going to go in to it.