The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Maxx]

Asking for role names is a pathetic way to play if you're town, unless you're in a game where the theme is really abstract and it's hard to pin down what roles would have made it in. NBA #1 Overall Draft Picks Mafia is a prime example of how lame the strategy of asking for role names and then compiling a giant list is. It's a game, it's supposed to be fun, you shouldn't be so obsessed with winning that you remove the fun element from the game.

[thuganomic]

Depends if he means individual scum tells, or general indicators that make someone likely to be scum.

thuggy used to have a scumtell where he would vote for Be purely because "it's Be." It was popular to hate Be, so it wasn't dangerous, no one wanted to be "that guy" defending Be.

Sort of like Be does to Potato Head now.

You keep saying that....except I actually did hate Be.

[EWB's Best Poster.]

Did is past tense, I assume it blossomed into luuuuuurve?

[EWB's Best Poster.]

Ohhhhh myyyyyyy

[Plubby]

Depends if he means individual scum tells, or general indicators that make someone likely to be scum.

thuggy used to have a scumtell where he would vote for Be purely because "it's Be." It was popular to hate Be, so it wasn't dangerous, no one wanted to be "that guy" defending Be.

Sort of like Be does to Potato Head now.

You keep saying that....except I actually did hate Be.

Sure, but that doesn't mean what I said was wrong

[Naitch]

Each set of twins should've been Masons in the HP game. It woud at least give the game a little more spice, seeing as everyone is vanilla.

[Guest mr. potato head]

What's wrong with vanilla?

[EWB's Best Poster.]

Gee i dont know. Could be that every vanilla game that runs people drop out like bitches.

I would know ive run two of them.

So i gave you kewl powers mafias instead.

[Gazz]

I think everybody should be doctor cops with day and night kills

[EWB's Best Poster.]

Thinking i may take the deadline off newbie mafias lynch or lose turn.

Random death because froot cant show up seems a lame way to endgame.

Thoughts?

[C-MIL]

Just end the game so somebody else can go.

[Noah]

Newbie mafia isnt taking up a spot though, is it? Id been thinking it was operating outside the quota as a special exception due to the need to school newbies.

[EWB's Best Poster.]

It isnt taking a spot at all, no. Cmil has a misconception.

If it took a slot I wouldnt be running two at a time.

So that aside still interested in thoughts. Id replace froot but its end game so few have much invested to not just slap a vote down and shrug. (We call that SDM Syndrome).

So replacements out yet random death is lame to end game since it WILL be random.

Just hope froots able to start posting more.

[NobBe Nobbs]

Depends if he means individual scum tells, or general indicators that make someone likely to be scum.

thuggy used to have a scumtell where he would vote for Be purely because "it's Be." It was popular to hate Be, so it wasn't dangerous, no one wanted to be "that guy" defending Be.

Sort of like Be does to Potato Head now.

You keep saying that....except I actually did hate Be.

Sure, but that doesn't mean what I said was wrong

I'd also like to point out I've advocated voting for Potato Head even when we're both part of the same Mafia group.

[Noah]

I honestly dont think itll end in random lynch Rider. I see someone getting lynched given a bit more time.

[EWB's Best Poster.]

I think so too with the exception of -a- and froot lacking consistent net.

Barring that i have no concern

[Guest mr. potato head]

Depends if he means individual scum tells, or general indicators that make someone likely to be scum.

thuggy used to have a scumtell where he would vote for Be purely because "it's Be." It was popular to hate Be, so it wasn't dangerous, no one wanted to be "that guy" defending Be.

Sort of like Be does to Potato Head now.

You keep saying that....except I actually did hate Be.

Sure, but that doesn't mean what I said was wrong

I'd also like to point out I've advocated voting for Potato Head even when we're both part of the same Mafia group.

Yes but that was just a cunning ploy. See me, LCS, Traditional Mafia I.

[Dingle]

Hey Rider, I could replace froot?

[EWB's Best Poster.]

Well you ARE on the same mafia team....

[DMN in the House]

Fuck powers, I want a traditional game!