That's actually my favorite Green Day album.
lol good for you lol
So finally got round to listening to this. It's hardly a car crash but it is most definitely too long. Musically solid but I really can't stand Armstrong's voice in a ballad context. Decent voice for poppy-punk songs, yes, but that's because having a good voice isn't of much importance in the field. So yeah, Green Day ditch something they are good at for a bit and try something they're shit at. Fair play to them for trying something new. I don't hate them for it. I just hate the something new because it's shit. Nevertheless, they are pretty decent when they stick to what they're good at.
Ironically my favourite song on the album is a ballady one, being "21 Guns". I think I like it because it sounds a bit like a John Lennon reject, and as we all know, a John Lennon reject sounds like a reject from a Paul McCartney reject compilation album. But that's still good. Only problem with it - barring the lyrics which I'll discuss later - is that it suffers from being too long. If this was three minutes long it would most likely earn a place as the fourth Green Day song on my iPod (other three are When I Come Around, Who Wrote Holden Caulfield and One For The Razorbacks).
However the lyrics bring them down again. Which is a shame. Lyrically Green Day never struck me as being dreadful until "Minority". In truth, lyrics just tend to pass me by unless they are really really dreadfully bad(Sting, Jimi Hendrix, Nirvana) or really really exceptionally good(Idlewild, Death Cab For Cutie, Belle & Sebastian, Idlewild, Idlewild, Roddy Woomble when he's not doing Idlewild stuff). I'll let you guess what camp Green Day's last two albums fall into. Sometimes I get embarassed on Billie Joe's behalf.