I like it, although I'd mess with the track order a bit, and your 'be fair to each album' tactic means the omission of You Held the World and Actually Its Darkness in favour of some naffer Make Another World songs. And to be a really arsey completist I'd insist on some earlier stuff like Satan Polaroid or even Chandelier. And to be even more arsey I'd the acoustic hidden track version of Too Long Awake thats vastly better than the normal one. Okay, mine would be completely different...
I prefer the hidden acoustic Too Long Awake aswell but I suppose I tried to make it more commercial.
Or if we want to get really arsey, let's throw in the acoustic Self Healer and all the Mince Showercaps
Oh yeah, Make Another World is my favourite Idlewild album. I shall hear no bad mouthing of it >_<