I think we should discuss them because they are the 3rd best band ever and really do not get the mentions they deserve.
My favourite Bright Eyes album is probably "Cassadaga" which is as you may know their most recent effort. I like all of their albums though of course.
My favourites would be Cassadaga > I'm Wide Awake It's Morning > Fevers & Mirrors > Lifted Or The Story Is In The Soil Keep Your Ear To The Ground
They also do Landlocked Blues(also known as One Foot In Front Of The Other) which is one of my favourite ever songs. As is "Lua", "Soul Singer In A Session Band", "The City Has Sex", "You Will. You?Will. You? Will. You?Will.", "I Must Belong Somewhere" and "Noone Would Riot For Less".
Please don't talk about Art Garfunkel here eh?